Sakura Trick – Quelling the Hate

[Mezashite] Sakura Trick - 01 [CE6A102E].mkv_snapshot_06.29_[2015.11.12_19.55.10]


If you’re a fan of the series, you’ve probably stumbled across a truckload of hate being piled on the show, heck, even people who enjoyed it have considered it to be a guilt watch. The formula of Yuri and Kissing had certainly been an invitation for people to hurl the word objectification and dismiss the show for trying to be different. As someone who loves Sakura Trick, it is frustrating to see that it is so gravely misunderstood.

Fanservice

Let’s first look at one area this show has constantly been attacked, fanservice. I can understand a person being uncomfortable with fanservice in the series, but vocal haters are using this to draw their conclusion that the show is trying to objectify lesbians, its even to the point that they think the kissing is nothing more than service to the audience.

Now, there is something really wrong with the idea that girls kissing automatically equates to objectifying lesbians, is there not a need to view the situation in context? Their very first kiss establishes that they were special to each other and the second an attempt by Haruka to reaffirm this. They aren’t the normal cliche and drama fare, it may seem trivial, but these are all indicative of character motivations, quite the opposite of sexual objectification.Tokubetsu

To address the fanservice aspect, it is introduced mostly in the form of gratuitous shots, not by means of people falling on each other and magically ending up in a 69 position. It can put some people off, yes, but it in no way affects the characterization.

Story

“There’s no plot” is something that always comes up and this is one complaint I can’t for the sake of me understand. I take it they meant that there is no major conflict in ST, which is true, just that it shouldn’t be a problem in a Slice-of-Life series. In fact, comparing ST to other SOLs, the passage of time is clear and the characters show progression.ST

It is quite common to find heavy-handed drama in romance, throwing as much nonsense as possible at an established couple to show their relationship is so strong that they survived through: being framed of cheating, miscarriage, being separated for years, family opposition…

Some might find the idea of taking a grenade, getting stabbed and getting thrown in front of a train for the one you love is romantic, but I just find it plain creepy. Why talk about your love for a person through what you would and could do for them and not through the things you appreciate about them. There is a world of difference between being in love with a person and being in love with the idea of being in love.

Here we have something a little different from the norm, a romance which focuses on showing the intimate side of a couple. A show which rejects the idea that a romance must be depicted through overcoming attempts to tear the couple apart, one that chooses to express romance with romance.

Characters

Sakura Trick certainly isn’t in your face with it’s character development, it is all very subtle and focused more on what is seen and not said. Sadly, it is a subtlety which goes unappreciated. Even among those who can feel the characters it is difficult to convey them into words.

If we simply look at the start and end, we will have realized our MCs have come a long way since they first started their high school life. Yuu started off as being very confused and out of her element trying to accommodate Haruka’s feelings yet, at the end, we have a reversal where, under pressure of Mitsuki’s constant interference, Yuu is the one speaking up for their relationship and Haruka only wants to avoid conflict.[Mezashite] Sakura Trick - 02 [B70FB8E0].mkv_snapshot_20.30_[2015.11.13_21.48.20][Mezashite] Sakura Trick - 12 [177DA7E1].mkv_snapshot_08.50_[2015.11.13_21.49.57]

Haruka on the other hand was open to her passionate feelings from the start, what she didn’t know was whether Yuu would reciprocate. Initially hesitant and worrying, Haruka becomes confident of her place in Yuu’s heart.

SubHaruka DomHaruka


To end off, I’d like to touch a little on why I wrote all this. Now, I’m not deluded enough to believe someone with a negative disposition toward the series would change their mind after reading this, you’re not changing someone’s mind over the internet. What I do hope, however, is that those who do like the series to come to understand there is nothing wrong with liking it, that there is genuine value in the way the show portrays it’s romance.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Sakura Trick and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Sakura Trick – Quelling the Hate

  1. OG-Man says:

    Reblogged this on The Yuri Nation and commented:
    Seriously? Some fans are still calling this a guilty pleasure? I know some have their reasons but to call Sakura Trick a bad yuri show is an injustice reserved solely to the prudish and the highbrow, not the general yuri audience. It’s like saying too much kissing between women in a show that’s as gay as it gets is a bad thing. I like subtext and subtlety as much as the next person but if I were given a choice I WOULD PICK LEGITIMACY EVERY SINGLE TIME DAMN IT!
    Ending and breasts physics aside I see no other reason to call it a “guilty pleasure” or deem it hateful. Oh and it has actual romantic storylines FYI.

    But what do I know? I’m just a yuri fan who appreciates shows that don’t hold anything back. Like we don’t get enough of those huh? “sarcastic tone”.

    Anyway I’m sure some will do their best to justify their hate or guilt. Bring it on.

    Like

  2. Cytrus says:

    To be honest, this is a very slow-paced show, even compared to the average slice of life, and many people might naturally lose interest at some point – nothing to do with hate.

    Absolutely nothing to feel guilty about for liking this show, though. The people in for the fanservice will likely be among those dropping this show since, like you outline, what fanservice is present is ultimately far from the main focus of the show.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. yurimylove says:

    a well-written, convincing piece on this topic. I like it!

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Kai says:

    Hey, saw this post from OG’s reblog. I love it!

    I can certainly see why Sakura Trick received such criticisms, even though I don’t really notice them as much when I was watching it myself. I feel like as a show, Sakura Trick just suffers from the same “supposed” flaws most critics just tend to criticize in a cute girls doing cute things show-less drama, no character development, etc… Little did they know Sakura Trick is slightly better in all those aspects compared to it’s peers, just very subtle in it’s execution. And indeed, nothing wrong with liking it!

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Shoujo Aisha says:

    Oh wow, thanks for the comments, only took me like 2 days to realize I had them (New to the whole thing). In truth, I was expecting something more toward a figure of one comment after a few months, so it makes me really glad that there are still people interested in the topic of ST.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s